Save it and rent it? Or, sell it and pay down your mortgage?

November 3, 2023

Keep or sell?...

Ever wanted to run the numbers to determine if you should Save Your House and Rent It, or Sell it, and use the cash to lower your new mortgage balance?


Perhaps this doesn't apply to you, but do you know someone that would appreciate this data?


Well, thanks to my handy new excel spreadsheet, you can easily run the comparison for yourself or someone else, so that you can have total CLARITY regarding the very important decision to be made. Click this link to download it!


I just had the joy of helping a client with this thought process-

(Client's home is currently worth $334,000 and has a mortgage balance of $207,000.)


Did you know there are 3 income streams if you keep a house and rent it out? 


Think of it this way, if you only considered cashflow, $211.88/month may NOT be worth the hassle of being a landlord. Finding tenants, dealing with tenants, doing repairs, etc.


However, this client had had their current mortgage since 2021 and they've made great progress in their amortization schedule. Every month, $435.91 of their mortgage payment paid down their loan (principal payment).


Also, based on a conservative 3% rate of appreciation, the client's house value should be rising at least $835.00 per month! (3% per year of a $334,000 home!)


The total "wealth accumulation" would be $1,482.78 per month!!


If you consider the full housing expense per month (mortgage principal and interest, taxes and homeowners insurance, even assuming you need to replace one furnace per year $300/month or $3,600 annual, and have the property vacant 1 month of the year for turnover, you're still converting a $211.88 profit! I would consider this a conservative estimate. Sometimes tenants stay longer than 1 year, so you wouldn't have a vacancy, and sometimes you have years when nothing / very little breaks! 



Finally, what if you'd choose to sell the house instead and use the sale proceeds to pay down your new mortgage instead? 


Even if you had $100,280.00 in sale proceeds, and used it all to do a larger down payment, you'd save $34,776.47 in mortgage interest over a 5-year period- which is pretty cool! 


However, if you'd keep your home and rent it out, over a 5 year period you would generate $88,966.93 in net worth for yourself - how amazing is that! See the grand totals below! That beats selling the home by $54,190.46!


I have done this twice now, with the first two homes my wife and I bought, and it has been an exciting and dynamic experience to say the least!



I would be happy to prepare a custom spreadsheet analysis for you if you or someone you know would be interested in a report like this! Just shoot me a text at 414-488-0438

Contact Me

Can't wait to help you finance your new home. I service Southeast Wisconsin and beyond!

Contact Us

By entering your contact information, you are providing express written consent for Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation to contact you at the email and number you provided via telephone, mobile device, automated means like autodialing, text SMS/MMS and pre-recorded messages, even if you are registered on a corporate, state, or federal Do Not Call list. You are also acknowledging and agreeing to our terms of service and privacy policy. Consent is not required to use our services.

By Ethan Brooks February 21, 2025
How much net worth is your household missing out on if you wait?
By Ethan Brooks February 11, 2025
Don’t take my word for it! Ask 100+ of our country’s smartest economists!
By Ethan Brooks January 24, 2025
And is it worth waiting for?
By Ethan Brooks January 17, 2025
The answer may surprise you!
By Ethan Brooks January 17, 2025
This is a subtitle for your new post
By Ethan Brooks January 17, 2025
This is a subtitle for your new post
January 10, 2025
You have options!
By Ethan Brooks December 13, 2024
A house is ultimately worth what people are willing to pay for it, right?
By Ethan Brooks October 21, 2024
Do your tax returns not tell the whole story? No Problem!
By Ethan Brooks October 11, 2024
For those waiting for house prices to fall in Wisconsin the last couple years, they may need to keep waiting for a while!
More Posts
Share by: